aY Dashes, spaces, and incompetence
Take, if you would, a look at your credit card. Unless you come from a different planet, chances are that it, like mine, has a series of digits separated by spaces. Depending on which kind of card you're looking at, these numbers may be grouped in different ways, but, generally speaking, this is probably a valid statement for every kind of credit card in existence.
Those spaces are there for a very specific purpose: they break the visual flow of your credit card number, providing your brain with anchors that it can use to group the digits together in a way that makes them easy to process. Although the number as a whole is no easier to remember, it's much simpler to copy and compare something like ao123 457 789a than ao123457789.a
Why, then, do so many developers still insist on asking users to enter their credit card numbers aowithout dashes or spaces?a
The problem here is not just one of developer laziness. Sure-in the specific example of credit card numbers, all that needs to be done at the code level can be expressed with a regular expression that borders on the stupid:
$creditCardNumber = preg_replace('/\D/', '', $originalCardNumber);
In some other cases, building good heuristics that are flexible enough while providing the proper constraints can be a little trickier, but the real issue is that so many programmers don't even try. And that, unless you're writing your applications in assembler, is simply incompetence.
There is a beautiful concept in cognitive psychology called learned helplessness. The basic idea behind it is that people who repeatedly fail at a task will eventually blame themselves for the failure and give up trying to do it.
This, in a nutshell, describes perfectly the way I see most non-technical folk relate to computers. They've just been hit so many times by software that makes no sense to them that they approach every task with fear and uncertainty-instead of making users more productive (and, therefore, happier), software makes them more depressed.
Why does this happen? Because of a million little (and big) things like the credit card snafu. Every time the user encounters a scenario in which an application creates a disconnect between reality (spaces on my credit card) and its software representation (no spaces or dashes!), the sense of helplessness increases, and productivity decreases as a result.
Let me fix this for you
The good news is, this kind of problem is due entirely to developer incompetence, which makes it easy to fix-after all, there are far fewer of us than there are users, so education should be a far simpler task.
In the specific example of credit cards, the issue is usually related to the fact that the upstream credit card provider requires that numbers be passed to them without any extraneous character, and we simply transfer that constraint up to our downstream user.
However, the constraint is not transitive: it makes sense in one direction because the provider has created an interface built for engineers, who (at least in principle) should be able to deal with the resulting requirements. Our users possess no such ability, and expect an interface built for them.
From a more general perspective, solving this kind of problem is not that difficult: you simply need to look at the constraints you create from the user's point of view. Credit cards numbers have spaces in them in real life, and that's how users will want to input them. There. Simple as pie.
This doesn't mean, however. that you need to take this too far in the other direction and create skeuomorphs that attempt to reproduce reality too closely. For example, making your credit card input form look like a credit card is dangerous because the various types of credit cards are different enough that it could create confusion instead of dispelling it. Besides, the user is probably capable of abstracting the underlying data model enough that such a skeuomorph would feel patronizing.
And, please, do not think that this is something that only designers should worry about. Developers are meant to solve problems, not churn out bytes. If you don't want to be treated like a code monkey, stop acting like one.